So ... are you circumcised, or have you been circumcised? I, most definitely, am!!
Replies
- NU
Jun 17, 2015When I say it; during an adult like conversation, I say it as both a statement acknowledging that it's best for me and my partner, also as an event that was required
ReactReply - TO
Jun 18, 2015I am circumcised. I chose to be at the age of 22. It is/was a personal choice for me and I am still happy with that decision 41 years later. When I am asked why I had it done, I usually reply "I got tired of looking at the same old thing."ReactReply - FU
Jun 18, 2015its sort of the same thing isn't it? if you are circumcised then you are circumcised and have been circumcised. I was not circumcised until I was 36, through choice, so I am circumcised and have been circumcised. its semantics. and I like being circumcised personally and did it because I wanted to be, but I disagree with routine circumcision as a baby if no medical reasons are present. but I am much more than my penis and if I am asked directly for whatever reason the state of my penis in regard to its foreskin then I say I am circumcised. simple!ReactReply - NA
Jun 18, 2015Hmmm, that is something to think about. While at present I am, I also was. When asked if I am, my reply is yes. When asked when, I say at birth. So, was I or am I? I am, therefore I was. But then again, if I wasn't, would I be? A question to ponder on. I guess I shall never know. In answer to your question sir, I am therefore I was.ReactReply - ON
onlyconnectOriginal PosterJun 21, 2015Thanks for all these comments, and good to have a mix of RICs and by choice as adult. Yes, it is semantics, but then English is capable of such tiny gradations! I suppose what I am getting at is how far you regard it as part of your self-identity, and how far you regard as a one-off event. Perhaps the nearest parallel would be some other body-mod, such as a tattoo. Clearly, there was a time (however short) at which we were all uncircumcised, so we all 'have been circumcised'.ReactReply - SI
Aug 21, 2015I was circumcised as a baby and okay with it so I am. When we had boys my wife and I went around and around over the decision of wether they should be. I said yes because I thought they might think they were odd not looking like the father when younger so they were. Now they are in college and they have never asked me why they were so I don't think it bothers them or there has been any emotional scarring. If I was to do it all over I'm not sure. I think I'll ask them if they think they will have their sons cut if they have any.ReactReply - MEMemberAug 22, 2015[quote]I am and feel good about it[/quote] Same here and havent given it any thought as to why or what if i wasnt. I live my life with no regrets and thank my parents for the decision they made.ReactReply
- SI
Aug 22, 2015[quote]I tend to say that I opted to BECOM circumcised ten years ago. Thus, I guess I'd also be inclined to also say that I AM circumcised. To say that I WAS circumcised would seem to imply that it was someone else's decision, but this was something I elected to do on my own.
[/quote]And so??? Are you happy you had it done. Did you have to have it done? Do you miss the way it was? So many on here say which is better but honestly if we haven't been both ways we really never know.ReactReply - ON
onlyconnectOriginal PosterAug 22, 2015[quote]I tend to say that I opted to BECOM circumcised ten years ago. Thus, I guess I'd also be inclined to also say that I AM circumcised. To say that I WAS circumcised would seem to imply that it was someone else's decision, but this was something I elected to do on my own.
[/quote]There is also the choice element, for those of us who took that route. 'I got circumcised at 18', or 'I had myself circumcised in 1998' implies an active element in the process.ReactReply - PAOct 31, 2016[quote]Some men I know say 'I am circumcised', a state in which they are, like 'I am bald/hairy/short ...'. Other guys say 'I have been circumcised', and it was an event, like 'I have been vaccinated'. (When referring to the actual operations everyone says 'I was circumcised as a baby/man ...').
So ... are you circumcised, or have you been circumcised? I, most definitely, am!![/quote]I think its both a state and an event. i had myself circumcised when i was in my 50s. No regrets, love it. and yes im in a circumcised state which i am very happy with. Helmets rule.ReactReply - FU
Oct 31, 2016I have always been circumcised from birth and it looks far better than uncut. All my friends are uncut and some are jealous of me as the ladies love my circumcised cock.ReactReply - GH
Nov 1, 2016I was circumcised as a baby so I do not know what its like to be uncut but I have been with a few guys thats have foreskins and there knobs seem so very sensitive and feel good in my mouth sucking them, but I do like cut cocks better, but would not turn one down as I like both..Dave
ReactReply - TINov 1, 2016well as was circumcised as a baby so ive never known what its like to have a foreskin,i if given the choice would choose to be circumcised .I like the look and the knowledge that i dont have to worry about smegma etc.
However i read other threads that some men feel like they;ve been robbed of something by being circumcised,mostly Americans where circumcision is more common over here in the uk its rarer and there seems to be more men wanting to be circumcised here,maybe its just the thought of wanting to be different.
Ive only ever had one partner say she found it strange me having no foreskin but mine was the 1st one she had come across.Ive had to show other girlfriends how to do certain things as things are different were your cir but they have soon got the idea and have all said they prefer a circumcised xxxx. Dont want to get too sexually descriptive here but i thought it was relevant Is it an event or a state of mind ford me its both for meReactReply - WA
Jan 1, 2017"I am circumcised." Since it was done before I can remember, it's another fact about my body, like "I am righthanded." If it was done late enough that I remembered it, I might use the event language instead.
ReactReply - FIFeb 21, 2017
I'm glad to see this topic still going. I feel like a lot of guys think of it as a state. I like that as it suggests the permanency of circumcision. a young friend of mine was circumcised recently and loves being able to say "I AM circumcised".
ReactReply - CI
Feb 22, 2017I think I have to say I was as I was cut when I was 4 years old and remember little about it!
ReactReply - MEMemberDec 11, 2021I AM Circumcised thecircumcisionis the was part. It's part of who I am and part of my own self identity. I have no regrets about my adult circumcision and feel that for me it was a new startReactReply
- JA
Mar 7, 2022For the first few years after the event it felt like an event. I would say 'I was circumcised x years ago' or 'I needed a circumcision' etc. Nowadays I'm just a circumcised guy.
ReactReply



