So ... are you circumcised, or have you been circumcised? I, most definitely, am!!
Replies
- JO
Apr 14, 2022I say both "I am circumcised " and " I was circumcised " so maybe I see it as a state and an event ?
It's not something I've really thought about.
All I know is " I was circumcised " so therefore " I am circumcised " and I'm glad I was and amReactReply - ON
onlyconnectOriginal PosterAug 15, 2022[quote]Interesting question... I 'was' circumcised twenty years ago (I celebrate the date) and I'd say I 'am' circumcised in the same way as I am bald and bearded and 5'9" because the fact that I am makes a difference to how I see myself. Being circumcised is part of my identity and I feel an affinity and connection with other guys who are too.[/quote] Interesting answer! I'd go with that: it was both an event and an ongoing state. 'Being circumcised is part of my identity' - oh yes, very much so I tend also to say 'I had myself circumcised', as that emphasizes the fact it was entirely my choice.ReactReply - MEMemberApr 10, 2023
I say both depending on the context of the conversation or the question that I'm answering. As someone who had the procedure for medical reasons and spent at least a year feeling that my new penis was foreign to me, it's important to recognise that it was an event out of my control that caused it. After accepting the fact and feeling comfortable in my own skin (or lack of it in that case), I can recognise it as a characteristic too.
ReactReply - NW
Apr 15, 2023i would agree npap69. is it something you got to discuss with other men?
ReactReply - MEMemberApr 15, 2023[quote]i would agree npap69. is it something you got to discuss with other men?[/quote] I have had many conversations about it with other men. Especially people who are in a similar situation as I was back then, and need to do it for medical reasonsReactReply
- NW
Apr 15, 2023It's great you got it sorted. Many men suffer in silence for years from tight foreskins and other problems.
I am really glad to be circumcised and would recommend it. It's good you got to discuss it.
ReactReply - JA
Apr 17, 2023[quote]I say both depending on the context of the conversation or the question that I'm answering. As someone who had the procedure for medical reasons and spent at least a year feeling that my new penis was foreign to me, it's important to recognise that it was an event out of my control that caused it. After accepting the fact and feeling comfortable in my own skin (or lack of it in that case), I can recognise it as a characteristic too.[/quote] That's kind of how I felt, like in the time after my circumcision, like I needed to infer that it was something that was done to me and was very much an event. Time changes a lot of things, it's now a long time ago for one thing and my attitude towards it and life in general has changed. Now I see it as a characteristic of who I am. I found my lack of choice in the matter hard to deal with at the time, but a lot of people have to accept changes to their bodies that are beyond control and in the grand scheme of things I can deal with the long term effects of being circumcised, especially as I get older and other things start to change also.ReactReply


